Racial Profiling Continues to Shape Our Prison Population

From yesterday's New York Times:

More than two decades after President Ronald Reagan escalated the war on drugs, arrests for drug sales or, more often, drug possession are still rising. And despite public debate and limited efforts to reduce them, large disparities persist in the rate at which blacks and whites are arrested and imprisoned for drug offenses, even though the two races use illegal drugs at roughly equal rates.

Two new reports, issued Monday by the Sentencing Project in Washington and by Human Rights Watch in New York, both say the racial disparities reflect, in large part, an overwhelming focus of law enforcement on drug use in low-income urban areas, with arrests and incarceration the main weapon.

It's essential that this type of research continues, although I think we know now what to expect when scholars take a look at the racial breakdown of our prison population. Our press and policy makers need to be aware of the impact this lock 'em all up mentality is having and if that means documenting these same depressing disparities every six months, then so be it.

I also think this shows the need for some new angles in the broader struggle for criminal justice reform. Hmmm, maybe some sort of innovative film project could be helpful?

I'm going have to go ahead an

I'm going have to go ahead and disagree with that. I am not racist. However, in the area that I am from, I tend to believe blacks use illegal drugs at a higher percentage than whites. And probably one reason they get caught (and I understand we are talking about "use" here) is because blacks tend to peddle their goods at a higher rate and more likely to do it in public. I don't know one hundred percent of the subject but those results would be believable in my area. I don't see white people standing on the street corners too often around metro.

The numbers don't lie

It is just a fact that people of color are no more likely to use drugs than whites. Of course, there are places one can go to find people of color engaged in drug activity, but open markets are a socioeconomic phenomena that isn't defined by race alone. In low-income communities, crime takes place in the open because many people don't have private spaces.

Obviously, simply searching and arresting young black and Hispanic men for drugs doesn't prove that young black and Hispanic men are more likely to have drugs. Think about this: if the police in your area believe, as you do, that most of the drug users in the area are black, who will they be watching? Who will they stop? Who will they be asking for permission to search? Paying more attention to black men ensures that you'll be arresting more black men, and so the cycle continues with each new arrest further justifying the profile.

If you had to walk past a cop with drugs in your pocket, would you rather be white or black?

But I think you also have to

But I think you also have to consider that whites tend to live mostly in more rural areas as opposed to urban areas. Urban areas are subject to more crime, higher police concentrations, more agressive police tactics (drug task forces in urban areas as opposed to a 1 cop per town or county in rural areas) and thus more police presence and thus more arrests....

Is it not possible that increased arrests of minorities have more to do with demographics (where people of certain races tend to live) rather than police profiling?

It's more complicated than that

Geography is a factor, certainly, and I wouldn't deny that simple logistics do play a role here. But that hardly explains away the profiling problem. I've seen mountains of data showing that people of color are more likely to be stopped by police, even in areas with equal or majority white populations.

I've also met former narcotics officers who were trained by supervisors to deprioritize investigations of suburban white suspects because their families are more likely to have influence and access to quality legal representation.

The criminal justice system is biased at every stage, from who police stop to who the jury finds guilty to who the parole board grants early release. It's often not deliberate, it's just the way the system functions. If one is uncomfortable with the notion that the criminal justice system is biased against people of color, then you can say instead that it shows favoritism towards white people. Whatever you call it, the effects are the same.

War on drugs??

After untold countless dollars spent on this "war", drugs are now cheaper than ever and much more readily available. Just as in the prohibition era, a multitude of fortunes have been made off society's attempts to regulate morality. Criminals seem to love it when something is made illegal. I wonder why that is.

The "war" has however succeeded in the construction of many new prisons and lots of bodies to fill them. The majority of these new prisons also seem to be operated by private industry. Must be some good money to be made by locking people up for smoking a joint, snorting a line, or whatever their flavor is.

How do you end the war??

TAKE THE PROFIT OUT OF IT!!! Legalize it!! You will still make some money by catching them driving under the influence etc.. However, who in their right mind would fly a private plane to Bogota, Columbia and buy a load of cocaine if they couldn't sell it for a profit?

Answer -- NOBODY!

Yes, you will still have some who get it to experiment. Yes, you will still have some junkies. You will also have some teenagers overdose. Just like we do now. HOWEVER, the majority of the problem will be gone because there would be no money in it.

Then you could close most of those new prisons at untold taxpayer savings. You could also get rid of the bloated, inefficient, government agency created to fix the situation. There would also be a significant reduction in the % of the population now being forced to attend those new crime colleges we like to call prison.

Honestly people, I'm asking you seriously, when have you ever seen the government solve any problem without creating a bigger mess than what they started with. The next thing they tell you is that they are under-staffed, under-budgeted, etc. etc. Leave the government where it should be. Building roads and providing for a national defense. Let the free market handle the rest.

History has proven, time and again, that there is not now and never has been a good government. All governments throughout history have eventually subjugated its citizens. The sad part is that the American people believe they are unique. The American people refuse to believe that any government, or authority, would not be acting in the best interest of the citizens.

I am afraid that the American people have slept too long this time. I fear that it is too late to put this country back on the right path. The path where the government serves the people and fears the people. The reality is that the people now fear the government.

After failing to win the war on drugs, now we entrust them to win the war on terror? Has every adult lost their mind? You are willing to give up your constitutional rights for a little illusion of security? The men who fought and died to defend this country and it's constitution must be so ashamed of what we have become.

wczasy last minute

John, yes good answer - NOBODY.

Podbor Klyuchevyh Slov

Good afternoon. Obscurity is a good thing. You can fail in obscurity. It removes the fear of failure.
I am from Italy and also am speaking English, please tell me right I wrote the following sentence: "And optimization services or our professional or free tools when we say seo we.What is on page optimization? According to webopedia on page optimization refers to a factors that have been effect on websites or web page listing in"

Thanks :). Stan.

Post new comment





*

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <div> <b> <i>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web and e-mail addresses are automatically converted into links.
Verify comment authorship
Captcha Image: you will need to recognize the text in it.
*
Please type in the letters/numbers that are shown in the image above.